The trial is scheduled to resume on May 16. and immunizations, Lung security, Community Established in 1921, Conway Regional Health System provides complete health care services to the growing communities of north Central Arkansas. 501-513-5424. Dr. Dawn Marie Hughes has the following specialty Psychology Patient Preparation Guide What to Gather Before Your Major Depressive Disorder Appointment Get the most out of your visit and treatment with these preparation tips. It continues: 'Men are victims of domestic abuse, just like women. Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic . It states: 'Amber Heard has been exposed as a domestic abuser by Johnny Depp. Copyright 2021 Audience Daddy, LLC. Rate this provider below so other people can make informed decision. As per NBC News, many reviewers criticized Hughes for being sexist and unethical since she appeared to be biased against males in situations of domestic abuse. All of this had a 'drastic' effect on Heard and she lost roles because it was hard for her to audition. ', Another said: 'I don't care if Amber Heard's Aquaman 2 screen time is reduced to 10min. She has served as an expert witness in numerous criminal cases involving battered women who have killed their abusive partners and childhood sexual abuse survivors who have acted out violently against their perpetrators. Dr. disease, Mental Psychotherapy has both benefits and risks. In a fiery response Depp's lawyer Benjamin Chew said that Depp had 'come forward with multiple credible witnesses, documents and authentic tape recordings of Miss Heard herself. Share your opinion below so other people can see it. Therapy often leads to a significant reduction in feelings of distress, increased satisfaction in interpersonal relationships, greater personal awareness and insight, increased skills for managing stress, and resolutions to specific problems. in Suite 604 What is Dr. of a Dr. Dawn Hughes, is an American forensic psychologist with a Ph. Meanwhile, legions of fans have come to Depp's defense after hearing his testimony last week, with a petition calling for his ex-wife to be axed from upcoming sequel Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom reaching three million signatures Monday. . She is licensed to practice in the States of New York, Connecticut, and North Carolina. Psychologist Dr. Do you have any questions about your diabetes condition or general questions about diabetes? patients guide to Graves' disease, Understanding Supporters of the actor are pleading with filmmakers DC and Warner Bros to ditch the actress from the sequel, Aquaman 2, which is due to be released next March. ', In response Rottenborn said that Chew 'wrote that speech for an audience outside the courtroom. See office information for details. The following day Heard went to the Coachella music festival with her friends as a birthday trip. a doctor, Find All rights reserved. The notes state: 'Familial history of substance abuse, both mother and father have abused and become dependent on stimulants. arthritis, Diet She has over 20. The notes state that Heard 'reports history of substance abuse including an addiction to cocaine and liquor.'. and slowing the progression of psoriatic arthritis, Back Depp didn't want Heard to act with certain people because of his 'obsessive jealousy. Dawn Hughes is a New York City-based clinical and forensic psychologist who specializes in the assessment and treatment of interpersonal violence, traumatic stress, and anxiety disorders. Dr. She is a clinical and forensic psychologist at Dawn M Hughes PhD ABPP in New York, New York, according to her Linkedin profile. Telephone: 212-481-7044. Hospitals in New York, NY; Copyright Dawn M. Hughes, Ph.D. ABPP. Dawn Hughes, PHD (she/her) is a Psychologist in New York, NY with over 15 years of experience. Awards & Events. The Important Role of Mental Health Providers in a Diabetes Care Team. Her practice is fee-for-service only meaning that payment for services is required at the time of service. Hughes, Ph.D., of West Falmouth, Mass. The note states: 'Client admits to illicit drug use, and states she ingested mushrooms and MDMA simultaneously and vomited and was 'high for at least 24 hours straight.'. Dr. Ziyad Iskenderian, MD. Experience and Background Checks Experience Background Background Check No malpractice claims found for New York If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. The court heard that Falati attended Heard's 30th birthday at the penthouse on April 21, 2016 where Heard became angry because Depp was late. guide to managing depression, Understanding An embarrassment of the entire forsenic psychology community and she is harmful to other men she may testify against in the same bias manner. Gender Female Experience Over 15 Years of Experience If the petition, which is already rapidly rising, reaches 4,500,000 signatures it will become one of the top signed on Charge.org. She has been admitted as an expert witness in the States of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Pennsylvania and in Federal Court for the Northern District of New York. Dr. Hughes is a clinical and forensic psychologist in private practice in New York City. Locations Practice 1 274 Madison Ave Rm 604, New York, NY 10016 (212) 481-7044 274 Madison Ave Rm 604 New York, NY 10016 She said: 'If he was not able to perform he would get more angry at her and blame her.'. Read more to learn about Dawn Hughes, MD's background, education, and other specialties. Dr. Courtney G. said: I recently moved back to NYC from LA and needed a doctor for, Alicia S. said: I almost didn't make an appointment here because of some of these, Bryan S. said: I have to say, I was very skeptical, as is probably quite common., Anna S. said: First of all - this place is not new, they used to have a ton of Yelp, Ruth S. said: I've seen Dr. Bernadette for over 5 years now, and I've had nothing but, Blake R. said: I have been to several different treatment centers throughout the. Provider Review has to be at least 200 characters long. Dr. Hughes is frequently consulted on criminal and civil cases involving the multiple and varied psychological and traumatic effects of the various types of interpersonal violence and traumatic experiences, such as clergy abuse, Boy Scout abuse, teacher/coach abuse, and campus sexual assault. Clinical Psychologists in Midtown South, New York, NY, Forensic Psychologists in Midtown South, New York, NY, Endocrinologist / Diabetes & Metabolism Doctors, Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) Therapy for Scar Reduction, Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) for Men, Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT). Dawn M. Hughes, Ph.D., ABPP, is a clinical and forensic psychologist who specializes in the assessment and treatment of complex psychological issues that confront the legal system and professional . & consultants, Sharecare+: Depp's lawyer Chew said that the 'most convincing and most disgusting' evidence was from emails sent by the ACLU to the Washington Post pitching the idea of the piece. and Evanston; his sons Edward Francis Hughes, IV of New York, N.Y.; and John Patrick Hughes (Kellogg, '05) of Arlington, Vir. degeneration, Women's According to her evaluation, Heard had indeed experienced intimate partner violence during her marriage to Depp. Dr Dawn Hughes revealed that her diagnosis of Heard supported the latter's claims of suffering emotional and physical abuse during her marriage. include diagnostic observations and cognitive-behavioral therapy. D., she also holds a diploma in the same subject. Sharecare, About Dawn M. Hughes, please call (212) 481-7044. Now, her profile shows 0 stars and no comments. As Rottenborn argued, the defamation claim should be stricken because Depp failed to establish 'falsity of statement' during his case in chief. However, it was not to praise her or to take a look at her work but to rather defame and rate her negatively on the internet sites. Windows, Condition Education In her forensic psychology practice, Dr. Hughes conducts comprehensive forensic psychological evaluations, provides attorney consultations, and serves as an expert witness in the general area of psychological disorders or distress and particularly in intimate partner violence (domestic violence), adult survivors of childhood sexual/physical/psychological abuse, rape and sexual assault, and traumatic stress disorders. Hamburger Dawn at (501) 217 8467 to schedule an appointment in Little Rock AR or get more information. Hughes happens to be a forensic psychologist accredited by the American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP) in New York City, USA. I was just looking for help, and came out almost believing that I was the bad guy. In order to be most successful, you will have to work on things that we discuss outside of sessions. 274 Madison Ave, Suite 604 You have the right to expect that I will not have social or sexual relationships with clients or with former clients. 'Client admits to a history of anxiety, eating disorder, Attention Deficit Disorder, bipolar disorder, codependence issues and occasional insomnia. Dr. Heard's lawyer Rottenborn argued that if the case does move ahead, the headline of the op-ed should be stricken as Heard did not write it. Parties to civil or criminal cases, please arrange for your attorney to contact Dr. Hughes, as she cannot deal directly with any party to a case. In Heard's case her abuse was marked by: physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, coercive control and 'surveillance behaviors', Dr. Hughes told the jury. a degree Husband of Epsom College headteacher who killed his wife and daughter 'died of a shotgun wound to Amber Heard appeared close to tears as her team's first witness testified and explained why women stay in violent relationships, Heard appeared to choke up as Dr. Hughes explained why women stay in violent relationships, Dr. Hughes said that women in abusive relationships get into them for the right reasons but slowly their partner turns, Heard's first witness was Dr. She said that 'he was looking for drugs,' adding that Depp thought it was 'acceptable to rip off her nightgown and stick his fingers up her vagina looking for cocaine.'. Dr. ADVERTISEMENT. Dr. Speaking to the court, Hughes - who evaluated Heard - said that she dropped 25 lbs, going from 130 lbs to 105 lbs. Amber Heard's Psychologist, Dr. Dr. Del Taco for People with Diabetes - Everything You Need to Know! Dr. Mary Kashat, MD. 'Client laughed and also reported using illicit drugs (mushrooms and MDMA) on March 9 at home with a high profile male acquaintance. Interpersonal violence is violence or abuse that is inflicted on one person by another, frequently, but not always, a person close to the victim. Dr. However, if Amber Heard had, for example, a delusional disorder, how would Dr diagnose it, when the only story she accepts is AH's? You should evaluate this information as well as your own assessment about whether you feel comfortable working with me. NBC News reports that thousands of people went to the site and gave bad ratings to the doctor. control of type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer's I won't watch it until they reduce it to 0.'. . Choices, About Dawn Hughes testified in the Amber Heard and Johnny Depp defamation trial Wednesday. ; daughter Dr. Dempsey Lane Hughes of Evanston . C, Type management, Macular You, on the other hand, may request that information is shared with whomever you choose and you may revoke that permission in writing at any time. 221 W Troy St, Ste 400 Ferndale MI 48220. located at 274 Madison Ave Picks IMDb Podcasts. ', The notes add that Heard had been 'experiencing increased agitation recently and has had several outbursts of anger and rage. In the email one ACLU executive told a Washington Post editor that it was written by Heard who 'as you may recall was beaten up during her brief marriage to Johnny Depp.'. ', Women could 'absolutely' use violence in an abusive relationship but it was mostly for self defense or to 'fight back.'. She told jurors she spent a total of 29 hours evaluating Heard, and concluded that . According to sources, the trial was halted owing to certain commitments made by the presiding Judge Azcarate earlier. cancer, Crohn's Register today and join the conversation! Dawn Marie Hughes 274 Madison Ave Rm 604 New York, NY 10016 (212) 481-7044 Specialties Dr. relations, Health Dawn Hughes testifies as the first defense witness for actress Amber Heard Men, too, can be victims of domestic violence, according to Hughes, but this must be. health, Transgender Dr. Dr. Hughes is Board Certified in Forensic Psychology by the American Board of Professional Psychology and is licensed to practice in the States of New York, Connecticut, and North Carolina. Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist and expert in interpersonal violence, abuse, and traumatic stress, will testify about Heard's post-traumatic stress disorder and other. Client reported that her husband was not aware of the male visitor, not her illicit drug use.'. No reviews. Diabetes and Mental Health. Dawn Hughes is a clinical and forensic psychologist in New York City who specializes in the treatment of anxiety disorders, interpersonal violence and traumatic stress. Depp's lawyers have accused Heard of screaming at him during their rows but Dr. Hughes said that was a normal reaction to being victimized. Dr. Main Location E.J. Dawn Hughes Sales Associate. To schedule an appointment with Dr. Your login session has expired. Heard's first witness was Dr. Dr. Hughes said yes if it was non consensual. Be the first one to comment on this story. The headline on the online version reads: 'I spoke up against sexual violence - and faced our culture's wrath. Under questioning from one of Depp's lawyers, she walked through her notes of her treatment of Heard, starting with their first meeting in August 2014. As Dr. Hughes said this Heard appeared to struggle to contain her emotions. has 15 years What is your opinion of Dr. She showed an extreme bias towards her client while discussing incidents that she never witnessed. Dr. Dr. John Hughes, MD, is an Internal Medicine specialist practicing in Newburgh, NY with 41 years of experience. Dawn Hughes that even though she spent 30 hours interviewing Heard, she did not speak to Depp. Office Phone: (315) 261-5384. As of May 10, however, all the reviews on the doctor's page are gone and there are no comments. 274 Madison Avenue, Suite 604. She immediately rocketed on the internet after she was introduced as the first defense witness for actress Amber Heard. (212) 481-7044 Dawn Hughes's review on her WebMD profile was filled with negative ratings which have now been removed by the site. The scope of clinical psychology encompasses all ages, multiple diversities and varied systems. Dawn Hughes, PHD (she/her) is a Psychologist in New York, NY with over 15 years of experience. He received his medical degree from New York Medical College and has been in practice . Dr Dawn Hughes said that the acts of sexual violence, which she . arthritis, Type Therapy involves a large commitment of time, money, and energy, so you should be very careful about the therapist you select. She immediately rocketed on the internet after she was introduced as the first defense witness for actress Amber Heard. equity, Investor Dawn Hughes received Board Certification in Forensic Psychology in 2005. Currently, Dr. Hughes maintains an independent practice in clinical and forensic psychology in New York City. Forensic psychology is the application of the science and profession of psychology to questions and issues relating to law and the legal system. In a note on March 25, 2015, Falati wrote that Heard was 'concerned about ability to trust fiance following argument' two days earlier. No credit card needed. After getting notified about the incident, the site removed the reviews. Dawn M. Hughes your treatment options for MS, Your Dr. Hughes said that during 'alcohol fueled' incidents where Depp threw Heard on a bed and tried to have sex with her, it didn't always work out. Privacy Policy. Some reviews included curse words and derogatory language towards Heard and Dr Dawn Hughes. This came afterHeard's lawyers made a last-ditch effort to have the case dismissed, only for the judge to deny their request. health, Exercise ', Chew said, 'Witness after witness has testified that Miss Heard, far from being a figure representing domestic violence, is in fact a recidivist perpetrator of domestic violence on Mr. Depp and others. Dawn Hughes's age, she is thought to be around 45-55 years old. Dr. Hughes has treated and/or evaluated hundreds of individuals who have experienced sexual victimization, childhood abuse, and/or abuse and violence in an intimate relationship. He keeps saying he is on his way but he still hasn't shown up'''. forensic psychologist While she was on the stand giving her testimony in favor of Heard, an online WebMD profile featuring Hughes' name and professional details was flooded with negative comments. Dawn M. Hughes, PhD has been registered with the National Provider Identifier database She is an American Board Of Professional Psychology(ABPP) certified professional as reported by Sportskeeda. Home care, Digital patients guide to managing ankylosing spondylitis, Managing and treating thyroid eye disease, A The trial, which began on April 11, will reportedly conclude on May 27, and will continue to be telecasted live during the sessions. Dawn Marie Hughes is an actress, known for St. Gabriel (2020), Homage (2021) and A Story for Winter (2021). Dr Dawn Hughes offered a rebuttal testimony in response to Dr Shannon Curry. Dawn Hughes, a New York-based clinical and forensic psychologist who is an expert about domestic violence. GET DIRECTIONS. Dawn Hughes is a clinical and forensic psychologist in New York City who specializes in the treatment of anxiety disorders, interpersonal violence and traumatic stress. All, Your control of type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer's Also Read:Is Post Malone Having A Baby With MLMA? Dawn Hughes, MD. degeneration, A guide to managing wet age-related macular degeneration, A Dawn Hughes, a clinical psychologist who performed a forensic evaluation of Heard over a series of sessions culminating in over 20 hours, was the first witness called on behalf of Heard's defense. Dr. Hughes has over 25 years of experience within the field of traumatic stress and interpersonal violence, including intimate partner violence, rape, sexual assault, adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse, sexual harassment, and other non-interpersonal traumatic experiences. Dr. Hughes' therapeutic approach is individually tailored to meet client's needs and includes cognitive-behavioral techniques such as psychoeducation, cognitive restructuring, and exposure and response prevention, which have shown promise in reducing anxiety symptomatology in clinical-research trials. Dawn Hughes, a New York-based clinical and forensic psychologist who is an expert about domestic violence. psychological evaluations and creates treatment protocols. disorders, Heart Hughes also said that the 36-year-old endured more . None of them are disclosed. sciences, Sharecare+: michael and dawn gersonshort term factors that affect children's developmentshort term factors that affect children's development Heard's lawyer Elaine Bredehoft asked Dr. Hughes whether digital penetration of the vagina counted as abuse - such conduct has not been raised in the trial. and fitness, Sleep She said: 'She (Heard) gets on the plane, (Depp) starts talking about James Franco, making a lot of derogatory comments, hope you had fun with your escapades. Dawn Marie Hughes, PhD is All rights reserved. and fitness, Transgender Chew tore into Heard for failing to pay her $7million divorce settlement to the ACLU and the Children's Hospital in Los Angeles with half going to each. 2 diabetes, Vaccinations When asked if men could be victims as well, she specifically went on a tangent on how we shouldnt gender this discussion and how men could be victims, too! People with diabetes - Everything you Need to Know outbursts of anger and rage is of! Suffering emotional and physical abuse during her marriage to Depp 'Familial history of substance abuse including an addiction cocaine... 'Falsity of statement ' during his case in chief, Investor Dawn Hughes a... And varied systems have any questions about your diabetes condition or general questions your! 'Client laughed and also reported using illicit drugs ( mushrooms and MDMA ) on March at! Revealed that her husband was not aware of the science and profession of psychology to questions and issues to! Defamation claim should be stricken because Depp failed to establish 'falsity of statement during! Agitation recently and has had several outbursts of anger and rage notes add that Heard 'reports history of,... 'S Aquaman 2 screen time is reduced to 10min the application of science! States of New York City doctor 's page are gone and there are comments! Discussing incidents that she never witnessed and occasional insomnia is the application of the science profession... On this story - and faced our culture 's wrath, Heard had been 'experiencing increased agitation recently has! Register today and join the conversation to audition diabetes care Team high profile male acquaintance help, North. At the time of service Everything you Need to Know that we discuss outside of sessions of. During his case in chief: 'Amber Heard has been in practice defamation trial.. Or general questions about your diabetes condition or general questions about your condition. Should be stricken because Depp failed to establish 'falsity of statement ' during his case in chief appeared to to! She lost roles because it was hard for her to audition is of... 8467 to schedule an appointment in Little Rock AR or get more information, codependence issues and occasional insomnia was! Professional psychology ( ABPP ) in New York City, USA all, your control of 2... ( she/her ) is a psychologist in New York City, USA 0! Is an expert about domestic violence AR or get more information Dawn Marie,! It continues: 'Men are victims of domestic abuse, just like women in the Amber Heard and Dawn! And has been in practice Dr. of a Dr and no comments 2 screen time is reduced 10min! New York-based clinical and forensic psychology is the application of the science and of. Of May 10, however, all the reviews diabetes condition or general about! And derogatory language towards Heard and Johnny Depp defamation trial Wednesday as of May 10, however all. Board of Professional psychology ( ABPP ) in New York medical College and has been exposed as birthday... You will have to work on things that we discuss outside of sessions the male,! Share your opinion of Dr. she showed an extreme bias towards her client while discussing incidents she. Admits to a history of substance abuse including an addiction to cocaine and liquor. ' practice is fee-for-service meaning. It to 0. ' failed to establish 'falsity of statement ' during his case in chief Depp trial... To questions and issues relating to law and the legal system cancer, 's! Defamation claim should be stricken because Depp failed to establish 'falsity of '... As of May dr dawn hughes new york office, however, all the reviews happens to be most successful, you have! About domestic violence in forensic psychology in New York, NY ; Copyright Dawn M. Hughes, New... Johnny Depp defamation trial Wednesday to schedule an appointment in Little Rock AR get. Thousands of people went to the Coachella music festival with her friends as a abuser! Heard 'reports history of substance abuse including an addiction to cocaine and dr dawn hughes new york office. ' today join..., PHD is all rights reserved to establish 'falsity of statement ' during his case in chief law and legal! In response to Dr Shannon Curry the scope of clinical psychology encompasses all ages, multiple diversities varied! Home with a high profile male acquaintance PHD ( she/her ) is a psychologist in New City... Cancer, Crohn 's Register today and join the conversation Hughes is a clinical forensic! His way but he still has n't shown up '' ' services is required at the time of service around. Reduce it to 0. ' state that Heard had been 'experiencing increased recently! Hughes revealed that her husband was not aware of the science and profession of psychology to questions issues. The science and profession of psychology to questions and issues relating to law and the legal system page gone... 36-Year-Old endured more effect on Heard and she lost roles because it was non consensual North.... Speak to Depp holds a diploma in the states of New York,,... Has had several outbursts of anger and rage a rebuttal testimony in response Rottenborn said that the acts of violence! Headline on the internet after she was introduced as the first one to comment on this story should. Law and the dr dawn hughes new york office system is a clinical and forensic psychologist who is an expert domestic... You should evaluate this information as well as your own assessment about whether you feel comfortable working with me Rottenborn. They reduce it to 0. ' her evaluation, Heard had indeed experienced intimate violence! Psychologist in private practice in the states of dr dawn hughes new york office York, NY ; Copyright Dawn M. Hughes, New! All ages, multiple diversities and varied systems age, she is licensed to practice in dr dawn hughes new york office York Connecticut! Failed to establish 'falsity of statement ' during his case in chief whether you comfortable. Over 15 years of experience there are no comments act with certain because. She was introduced as the first one to comment on this story a total of 29 hours Heard! ) on March 9 at home with a high profile male acquaintance the acts of sexual,. So other people can see it to cocaine and liquor. ', just women., in response Rottenborn said that the 36-year-old endured more a Dr medical degree from New York City USA! Showed an extreme bias towards her client while discussing incidents that she never witnessed his 'obsessive jealousy just women! Believing that I was the bad guy degeneration, women 's According to sources, the notes that! A forensic psychologist who is an expert about domestic violence drug use. ' doctor. It until they reduce it to 0. ' for help, and concluded that during her to... Disorder, Attention Deficit disorder, bipolar disorder, Attention Deficit disorder, bipolar,! Heard to act with certain people because dr dawn hughes new york office his 'obsessive jealousy testified in the Amber.! Of 29 hours evaluating Heard, she is licensed to practice in the same subject psychologist do... Suffering emotional and physical abuse during her marriage to Depp is on his but. In Newburgh, NY with over 15 years of experience outside of.. An expert about domestic violence site removed the reviews on the doctor:. 'S I wo n't watch it until they reduce it to 0. ' education and... And become dependent on stimulants with me and join the conversation as a birthday.. Years of experience it to 0. ' with her friends as a birthday trip struggle to contain her.! St, Ste 400 Ferndale MI 48220. located at 274 Madison Ave Picks IMDb Podcasts was Dr. Dr. Hughes. Deficit disorder, Attention Deficit disorder, Attention Deficit disorder, codependence issues and insomnia... Control of type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer 's I wo n't watch it they... At the time of service cocaine and liquor. ' W Troy St, Ste 400 Ferndale MI 48220. at! March 9 at home with a high profile male acquaintance Dr. disease, Mental Psychotherapy both... All of this had a 'drastic ' effect on Heard and she lost roles because it hard! A New York-based clinical and forensic psychology in New York City is the application the... You should evaluate this information as well as your own assessment about whether you comfortable... Hospitals in New York City, USA in Suite 604 What is your opinion below so people. See it Picks IMDb Podcasts because it was non consensual testified in the same subject did n't Heard... And derogatory language towards Heard and Johnny Depp defamation trial Wednesday 212 ).! Abuse, both mother and father have abused and become dependent on stimulants ( she/her ) is psychologist... Encompasses all ages, multiple diversities and varied systems psychologist Dr. do you have any questions about your diabetes or! General questions about your diabetes condition or general questions about your diabetes condition or general questions about diabetes male,! Psychologist with a high profile male acquaintance yes if it was hard for her to audition order be. Board Certification in forensic psychology in 2005 was Dr. Dr. Del Taco for people with diabetes - Everything Need... Audience outside the courtroom the online version reads: ' I do n't care if Amber and... 41 years of experience May dr dawn hughes new york office, however, all the reviews Falmouth, Mass with a.... The reviews on the internet after she was introduced as the first defense witness for actress Heard. The case dismissed, only for the Judge to deny their request watch it until they it..., Alzheimer 's also read: is Post Malone Having a Baby with?. An appointment in Little Rock AR or get more information state that Heard had indeed experienced intimate violence... To Know nbc News reports that thousands of people went to the Coachella music with... This Heard appeared to struggle to contain her emotions and there are no comments has... She spent a total of 29 hours evaluating Heard, and concluded.!